Back to StoriesOlivia and Elisha

We met in Chicago back in 2017, on tinder (early adopters) and we hit it off immediately but our timing was off. We stayed friends on and off over the next five years and both knew we always wanted to give it one more try. In September 2022 we did and couldn't be happier.

Where, when and how did he propose?

Hoxton Hotel - Chicago, IL

We were supposed to be taking photos for a holiday card, but the rain cancelled those plans, so we spent the morning going to our favorite places in the city then stopped at the Hoxton Hotel for a quick coffee and it happened in a room off their main floor dining room. Eli threw a surprise engagement party at night for us so I attached the video of us walking in there. It was the best day ever!!! 

Tell us about your ring!

My ring is exactly what I wanted, an oval with a gold band, and hidden halo setting. Having grown up in De Pere, going with my family to shop at Rummeles, and babysitting all the Alpert kids, I was always hoping my ring would come from Rummeles and Eli made all my dreams come true!


Saved Items (0)
  • Use this space to save the products you like. To add a product here, simply click the icon.

Rummele’s Jewelers
Green Bay
  • 234 S. Adams Street, Green Bay, WI 54301
  • 920-432-0664
  • Regular Hours:
    Monday - Wednesday & Friday: 9:30am to 5:00pm
    Thursday: 9:30am to 7:00pm
  • Holiday Hours:
    Saturdays thru December 23: 10am to 3:00pm
  • Available by appointment on evenings and weekends.
Rummele's Jewelers in Fish Creek
  • 9405 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212
  • 920-868-2121
  • Rummele's Jewelers of Fish Creek is closed for the 2023 Season and will re-open at the end of May 2024.
Rummele's Jewelers Close

We value your privacy

On our website, we use services (including from third-party providers) that help us to improve our online presence. The following categories of cookies are used by us and can be managed in the cookie settings. We need your consent before being able to use these services. Alternatively, you may click to refuse to consent, or access more detailed information and change your preferences before consenting. Your preferences will apply to this website only. You can change your preferences at any time by clearing your browser history/cache or visiting our privacy policy page.

By authorizing third-party services, you allow the placement and the reading of cookies and the use of tracking technologies required to keep our website reliable and secure.

These cookies are required to run available services and to provide basic shopping functions. These cookies are exempt from consent according to the exceptions provided by the Article 82 of Data Protection Act.
These cookies provide a custom experience on our website.
These cookies allow us to measure visitors' traffic. They help allow us to understand which products and actions are more popular than others.

Review and set your consent preferences for each partner below. Some personal data is processed without your consent, but you have the right to object.

Rolex (Adobe Analytics and Content Square)

Privacy policy:
Purposes (consent)
Legitimate interest Purpose(S)

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings.