Back to StoriesCaitlin and Justin


When we arrived back at our hotel, he had worked with the concierge to coordinate the most beautiful set up. There were rose petals, candles and incredible flowers everywhere. He got down on one knee and popped the question! San Luis Obispo will forever be special to us. 


Where, when and how did he propose?

San Luis Obispo, CA.

We had planned to go to San Luis Obispo, California for the 4th of July weekend. I went to college in SLO and it is a special spot for us because it is where Justin asked me to be his girlfriend. Justin planned the day with everything we did on our first official date as girlfriend and boyfriend. We went on a hike, ate tasty BBQ for lunch, had an amazing dinner, and ended the night visiting a fun dive bar. When we arrived back at our hotel, he had worked with the concierge to coordinate the most beautiful set up. There were rose petals, candles and incredible flowers everywhere. He got down on one knee and popped the question! San Luis Obispo will forever be special to us. smiley


Tell us about your ring!

The ring is incredibly gorgeous; I have never seen anything like it. Justin and I worked together to design it because he was too nervous to pick something that I wouldn’t love. It is everything I ever hoped for and more! My dad also grew up close to Green Bay, Wisconsin and I am a huge Packers fan, so it was so special that he worked with Rummele’s to design the ring.


Instagram - caitlinm_wolf

Saved Items (0)
  • Use this space to save the products you like. To add a product here, simply click the icon.

Green Bay
  • 234 S. Adams Street, Green Bay, WI 54301
  • 920-432-0664
  • Regular Hours:
    Monday - Wednesday & Friday: 9:30am to 5:00pm
    Thursday: 9:30am to 7:00pm
  • Available by appointment on evenings and weekends.
Rummele's Jewelry Boutique in Fish Creek
  • 4192 Main St., Fish Creek, WI 54212
  • 920-868-2121
  • Rummele’s Jewelry Boutique in Fish Creek is open for the 2021 summer season. Please call to check hours ahead of your visit.